overview establishment clause
free-exercise clause
frequently asked questions cases & resources
 
print this   Print

'Christmas' 2, 'holiday' 0 in tree-terminology test

By The Associated Press,
First Amendment Center Online staff
11.05.09

State and local officials in two states have taken an early stand in the annual tug-of-war between 'Christmas' and 'holiday' trees in government-sponsored seasonal displays.

A spokeswoman for Kentucky Gov. Steve Beshear says the governor is calling the tree on the Capitol's front lawn a "Christmas" tree this holiday season.

And in Colorado, the Larimer County Sheriff's Department plans to decorate a Christmas tree again this year in a slap at what it calls "politically correct" holiday celebrations.

In Kentucky, a statement from Beshear’s administration last week sparked Christmas consternation by referring to the yet-to-be-chosen evergreen as a "holiday" tree. Some Christians were perturbed by the terminology.

Spokeswoman Kerri Richardson said the administration received a steady stream of e-mails and phone calls about the "holiday" tree. She says it's always been a Christmas tree to the governor, and it will be this year, too.

The governor is inviting critics of the "Christmas" tree to a lighting ceremony Nov. 30.

Meanwhile in Colorado, the Larimer County Sheriff’s Department tradition of calling its tree a Christmas tree started in 2007 after Sheriff Jim Alderden criticized Fort Collins city officials for debating whether city Christmas displays should be more secular.

The Sheriff's Department said yesterday that this year's display on its county-owned site would include a Nativity scene and a menorah. A tree-decorating ceremony is scheduled for Dec. 5.

The department says it also will sell shirts that say "Lighten Up. Just say 'Merry Christmas'" and "Wishing you a loud and politically incorrect 'Merry Christmas.'" The department says profits will go to its volunteer posse.


Related

Mich. Capitol conifer re-christened 'Christmas tree' (news)
'If you're going to have a tree, you might as well call it what it is,' Michigan Jewish Conference director says after lawmakers vote to change name. 11.30.06

Christmas trees going back up at Sea-Tac (news)
Rabbi who wanted menorah added to airport displays says he never wanted trees taken down. 12.12.06

Menorah in, Nativity scene out at Wash. statehouse (news)
After airport Christmas-tree controversy, Capitol in Olympia allows Hanukkah candelabrum but denies request for creche. 12.22.06

Wis. lawmaker seeks to ax state's 'holiday' tree (news)
Public hearing turns contentious as legislators, residents discuss state Rep. Marlin Schneider's plan to rename conifer 'Wisconsin State Christmas Tree.' 12.01.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Saturday, November 21, 2009 | 04:33:17
 SEARCH  MORE
religious liberty in public life issues >
ESTABLISHMENT CLAUSE
Ten Commandments, other displays & mottos
Tax exemptions
Charitable choice/faith-based initiatives
Legislative prayer
Vouchers
FREE-EXERCISE CLAUSE
Workplace religious liberty
RLUIPA, religious buildings & zoning
Blue laws
Prisoners' rights
Vaccination & religious exemptions