DALLAS — Two advocacy groups filed a federal lawsuit yesterday against a
western Texas school district on behalf of eight parents who say a Bible course
violates their religious liberty.
The American Civil Liberties Union and People for the American Way Foundation
sued the Ector County Independent School District in U.S. district court, asking the Odessa school
system to stop teaching the course. The Ector school board approved the course,
a high school elective, by a 4-2 vote in 2005.
"Religion is very important in my family and we are very involved in our
religious community. But the public schools are no place for religious
indoctrination that promotes certain beliefs that not all the kids in the school
share," Doug Hildebrand, an ordained Presbyterian deacon who is among the
plaintiffs, said in a written statement released by the ACLU.
School Superintendent Wendell Sollis said district officials were reviewing
the lawsuit with their lawyer.
"We are not going to debate the individual points of the suit publicly," he
said.
Mike Adkins, spokesman for the Ector Independent School District, has said
that the district is comfortable with its curriculum.
The Bible course teaches the King James version of the sacred text using
material produced by the Greensboro, N.C.-based National Council on Bible
Curriculum in Public Schools. The course uses the Bible as the students'
textbook.
The National Council said its curriculum is used in hundreds of school
districts, including more than 50 in Texas.
The Ector trustees chose the class over one offered by the Bible Literacy
Project, which uses the text The Bible and Its Influence and includes
broader discussions of other faiths.
Lisa Graybill, legal director of the ACLU of Texas, said the National Council
course is "basically a Sunday School class within the walls of a public
school."
Backers include David Barton, who operates a Web site that promotes helping
local officials develop policies that reflect biblical views and encourages
Christian involvement in civic affairs.
Other supporters include the conservative American Family Association, Eagle
Forum and Plano-based Liberty Legal Institute.
"There is no question that these Bible electives are constitutional," said
Kelly Shackelford, Liberty Legal's chief counsel. "The United States Supreme
Court has stated more than once that teaching about the Bible is not only
constitutional, but essential to a quality education. This lawsuit is a
loser."
Critics include the Austin-based Texas Freedom Network, a watchdog of the
religious right, which claims the coursework contains errors, dubious research
and blatantly favors a fundamentalist Protestant Christian view of the
Bible.
Kathy Miller, president of the group, said the lawsuit resulted from two
years of reckless decisions by Odessa officials. The Texas Freedom Network is
not a party to the suit.
"This is a case study in what happens when public officials put their own
religious and political agendas ahead of the interests of students and
taxpayers," Miller said. "Instead of model courses that respect both the Bible
and religious freedom, school board members created a model for promoting their
own religious views over everybody else's."