First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

Removal of Bush foes from presidential visit prompts lawsuit

By The Associated Press
11.23.05

Editor’s note: On Oct. 30, 2006, U.S. District Judge Wiley Y. Daniel refused to dismiss Leslie Weise and Alex Young’s lawsuit, rejecting motions by defendants Michael Casper and Jay Bob Klinkerman. Meanwhile, Karen Bauer, who also was ejected from the Bush event, did not join Weise and Young’s lawsuit for personal reasons.

DENVER — The American Civil Liberties Union has sued volunteers for an event with President Bush, saying they violated the civil rights of two people who were tossed out because of their political views.

Leslie Weise, 40, and Alex Young, 26, were escorted from the March 21 event after they arrived in a car with a bumper sticker reading "No more blood for oil," and wearing T-shirts saying "Stop the lies" under other clothes, according to the federal lawsuit filed on Nov. 21.

The suit names as defendants Michael Casper, Jay Bob Klinkerman and five unknown people who the ACLU says contributed to the decision to remove the pair.

"Hopefully we can identify people who helped shape the policy and helped carry it out," said volunteer ACLU attorney Martha Tierney.

Weise and Young thought Casper was a Secret Service agent because he wore a radio earpiece and a dark suit. Casper did not return calls to the Associated Press for this story.

Klinkerman, the head of the Colorado Federation of Young Republicans, did not have a listed phone number and did not return an e-mail message requesting comment.

Young and Weise were ejected before the president arrived to promote his proposal to revamp Social Security.

The suit seeks unspecified damages.

The ACLU said similar incidents had occurred at presidential town hall meetings in Arizona, North Dakota and New Hampshire.

"We will be highlighting the pattern of incidents ... to show that this was a concerted White House policy of violating the First Amendment rights of citizens," the ACLU said in a news release.

Last February, a "black list" of people banned from getting tickets to a visit from the president was published by The Forum newspaper of Fargo, N.D. The White House and the Republican Party denied such a list existed. Fargo police later said the list was created by a local volunteer involved in the ticket distribution.

Two women were removed from a Bush appearance at Pease International Tradeport in Portsmouth, N.H., on Feb. 16. Carol Shea-Porter and Susan Mayer wore sweaters when they entered, but removed them to expose T-shirts with the message, "Turn your back on Bush."

The women reportedly caused no disruptions and sat through the entire forum. According to news reports, event staffers sat around them, apparently trying to block the news media's view of their T-shirts, and at the end of the program they were taken out a side door by security personnel.


Update
Judge rules against 2 ejected from '05 Bush event
Plaintiffs were essentially arguing that they were not allowed to participate in president's speech, federal judge finds. 11.07.08

Previous
No prosecution in case of 3 ousted from Bush speech
Federal prosecutors say they lack evidence to file charges against man who told protesters they'd have to leave because of their bumper sticker. 08.01.05

Related

Bush protesters say White House keeping rally out of public eye

Nebraska anti-tax cut activists accuse authorities of trying to limit their visibility by assigning them to location half a mile away from plastics plant president will be visiting. 05.12.03

5 sue police chief over Bush protest arrests

Crawford, Texas, ordinance challenged as a violation of First Amendment freedom of assembly. 06.20.03

Kerry supporters sue over arrests at Bush rally
Two women claim federal agents conspired with Iowa law enforcement to deprive them of their free-speech, assembly rights. 05.01.05

Colo. man arrested after criticizing Cheney, lawsuit claims
Steven Howards accuses officials of arresting him on trumped-up allegations of assaulting vice president after he called administration's Iraq policies 'reprehensible.' 10.04.06

Ex-GOP candidate describes arrest at Kan. Bush rally
Dennis Hawver claims 'slam-dunk' freedom-of-expression defense, since no one waving pro-Bush or pro-Republican signs was arrested. 11.08.06

Government to pay $80K to pair arrested for anti-Bush T-shirts
Nicole and Jeffrey Rank were charged with trespassing at July 4, 2004, presidential rally at West Virginia Capitol after they refused to cover up shirts. 08.17.07

Lawsuit : Police discriminated against protesters during Bush visit
Nine New Mexicans, two groups say they were kept farther away from president than supporters when he attended private fundraiser. 01.20.08

Stifling protest: bad choice between law and order
By Gene Policinski Managing media moments is no justification for shutting out or shutting down those with an off-the-script message. 08.26.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Tuesday, February 9, 2010 | 14:37:30
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links