First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

Panel endorses Roberts

By The Associated Press
09.22.05

WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee today approved John Roberts' nomination as the next Supreme Court chief justice, virtually assuring the conservative judge's confirmation by the Senate next week.

Three Democrats joined the committee's 10 majority Republicans in a 13-5 vote to advance the nomination to the full Senate.

Five Democrats — Sens. Dianne Feinstein of California, Joseph Biden of Delaware, Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, Charles Schumer of New York and Dick Durbin of Illinois — opposed Roberts.

At times, the arguments over whether Roberts is an appropriate successor to the late William H. Rehnquist merged with senators' worries about whom President Bush will choose to be his next nominee to the Court, as the replacement for the retiring Sandra Day O'Connor.

The Senate's 44 Democrats seem to be split on whether they can, or should, mount even symbolic opposition to Roberts. His confirmation as the 109th Supreme Court justice is assured because most of the Senate's 55 Republicans are supporting him and Democrats have decided not to filibuster his nomination.

But Democrats who oppose his nomination said they couldn't take the risk that Roberts would prove a conservative ideologue on the Court.

Feinstein told a packed Judiciary Committee hearing room that her vote was decided after Roberts refused to fully answer questions from her and other Democrats in his confirmation hearing last week.

"I knew as little about what Judge Roberts really thought about issues after the hearings as I did before the hearing. This makes it very hard for me," said Feinstein, an abortion-rights supporter.

"I cannot in good conscience cast a 'yea' vote," she said. "I will cast a 'no' vote."

Biden said his vote was a close call, but Roberts "does not appear to share the same expansive view of fundamental rights of previous nominees I have supported. I'm unwilling to take the constitutional risk at this moment in the court's history."

Sen. Herb Kohl and Russ Feingold, both Wisconsin Democrats, and the committee's top Democrat, Patrick Leahy of Vermont, decided to support making the conservative judge the nation's 17th chief justice.

"I will vote my hopes today and not my fears," Kohl said.

Kohl said Roberts made it clear to him that he would be a modest judge, not an activist, and would approach arguments with an open mind.

"I take him at his word that he will steer the court to serve as an appropriate check on potential abuses of presidential power," Leahy told the committee and former Sen. Fred Thompson, Roberts' escort through the confirmation process, who watched from the crowd.

Those statements likely are directed at the president, who is expected to soon make public his choice to replace O'Connor, who has been a swing voter on many of the Supreme Court's controversial issues.


Update
Roberts' confirmation appears guaranteed
Meanwhile, Bush hints that his next high court nominee could be a minority or a woman. 09.26.05

Previous
Roberts on the First Amendment: excerpts from hearings
Transcript discussions, letters answering written followup questions touch on news media access, church-state, free speech, campaign finance, pornography, libel. 09.14.05

Related

Roberts on the First Amendment: excerpts from hearings

Transcript discussions, letters answering written followup questions touch on news media access, church-state, free speech, campaign finance, pornography, libel. 09.14.05

O’Connor a maverick on First Amendment cases

By Tony Mauro Retiring justice cast unpredictable but crucial votes, especially on religion cases. 07.05.05

High court nominee well-acquainted with First Amendment
Exclusive analysis by David L. Hudson Jr. As an attorney, John G. Roberts has handled many First Amendment cases in private, public sectors. 07.20.05

6 First Amendment cases on fall docket
By Tony Mauro Topics involve campus military recruiting, hallucinogenic tea, public-employee speech, abortion protests. 09.26.05

Biden's record long, mostly strong on free speech
By Courtney Holliday Delaware senator has dealt with issues of religious freedom, flag desecration and campaign finance. 10.01.08

William Rehnquist's First Amendment legacy


News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Tuesday, February 9, 2010 | 09:09:33
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links