Federal judge limits New Orleans’ Super Bowl ‘clean zone’
NEW ORLEANS — The city of New Orleans must scale back its plans for a “clean zone” where the use of banners, signs and flags would be restricted during Super Bowl week, a federal judge said yesterday.
U.S. District Judge Kurt Engelhardt’s temporary restraining order says the city can only enforce the limits in an area near the Superdome, where the game will be played Feb. 3. The city had also planned to enforce the rules in the French Quarter and surrounding neighborhoods.
The judge’s ruling comes after the American Civil Liberties Union of Louisiana filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of an activist and a street preacher. They claim a new city ordinance and a code-enforcement guide trample on their free-speech rights and limit their activities leading up to the title game between the Baltimore Ravens and San Francisco 49ers.
The ACLU asserts New Orleans adopted the new policies at the behest of the National Football League.
“The NFL asked them to do a whole bunch of things, including this,” said Marjorie Esman, ACLU of Louisiana executive director.
Esman says other Super Bowl host cities have enforced similar rules in recent years, but they have not been challenged in court before.
Engelhardt’s order says the plaintiffs showed a “likelihood of success” in arguing that enforcing a broader “clean zone” is impermissible under the First Amendment. He scheduled a meeting for Jan. 28 with lawyers for the city and ACLU to discuss the latter’s request for a preliminary injunction.
“It’s wonderful that the judge recognizes the city doesn’t have a right to curtail speech throughout a large chunk of the city,” Esman said.
The city, Mayor Mitch Landrieu and Police Superintendent Ronal Serpas are named as defendants in the suit.
“We disagree with the ACLU’s characterization of the Clean Zone,” said Ryan Berni, spokesman for the mayor. “The Clean Zone addresses issues such as signage, outdoor vending and erecting structures and tents that the City already permits. It is an additional temporary designation that seeks to protect the quality of life for residents and assists businesses in thriving during the Super Bowl. The City and other cities nationwide have instituted ‘clean zones’ for similar major events.”
New Orleans planned for its measure to take effect on the morning of Jan. 28 and end on the evening of Feb. 5.
The ordinance, passed last month, says banners, flags and signs aren’t allowed in the “clean zone” without the authorization of the city or the NFL. The content of any temporary signs approved by the city must consist of at least 60% Super Bowl or NFL branding. The guide, meanwhile, says no signs will be permitted unless the applicant is an NFL sponsor, the suit says.
The plaintiffs are Tara Jill Ciccarone, an Occupy NOLA member, and Troy Bohn, pastor of a religious congregation that regularly preaches on Bourbon Street.