Posts by Douglas E. Lee:
Ruling in Ill. anonymous-speech case is a win — for now
In its opinion, state appeals court notes that the standard for obtaining the identity of an online poster to a newspaper comment board is relatively low.
Foul language doesn’t invalidate petition, court rules
Fed up with officials in Loveland, Colo., contractor let loose with choice epithets, whereupon, he alleges, the city retaliated against him.
Permit rules can discourage what should be lawful protest
Refusing to follow rulings in other circuits, 7th Circuit decides to give a Chicago agency a chance to defend its permit policy regarding undefined ‘expressive activity.’
TV station wins ruling on exclusion of candidate from debate
Because it is privately owned, WTTW-11 in Chicago is not a state agent under the First Amendment, district judge rules.
Agency doesn’t have to turn over Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac info
Several politicians likely are breathing easier after federal appeals court decides that records detailing campaign contributions aren’t subject to FOIA.
7th Circuit OKs limits on inmates’ possession of public records
Court upholds a Wisconsin prison rule that defines ‘contraband’ to include documents obtained under the state’s open-records act that don’t refer to the inmate.
Court tosses portion of Texas charitable-solicitations rules
5th Circuit relies on a trio of high court precedents from the 1980s in striking down part of state’s disclosure requirements for for-profit companies that collect or solicit donated goods for charities.
Transit hearings in Big Apple must be open
Fare-skippers, graffiti artists and others no longer can hope to keep their infractions secret after 2nd Circuit rules that people who are cited can’t refuse to allow observers into their hearings.
How local journalists fight government secrecy — every day
Across America, local governments try to act in secret and keep information quiet, and if it weren’t for local journalists, they’d get away with it.
Girl Scouts can’t claim free-speech right to drop councils
7th Circuit rules national organization’s claim that its First Amendment protections allow it to eliminate local councils doesn’t hold water.
Public worker wins a round vs. college that fired her
At least for now, Laura Vera’s retaliation case has avoided capsizing in the dangerous legal waters created by the Supreme Court in Garcetti v. Ceballos.
Ala. ruling reaffirms: Journalists can report rumors
Case involved newspaper’s report of rumors concerning a public official’s government duties; state appeals court says journalists aren’t obligated to investigate whether rumors are true.
Facing unresolved constitutional issue, judge sides with free speech
Federal judge’s refusal to apply public-concern test to retaliation claim brought by private citizen likely will expand First Amendment protection in 7th Circuit.















Press Commentary | Douglas E. Lee | December 19, 2011
Troubling rulings paved way for blogger’s libel conviction
Whether bloggers being sued for libel are entitled to the same First Amendment protections as non-media defendants should be beyond controversy.